Education, Choice and Expectations
Have just finished the first 2 chapters in a new book I bought today (while waiting for ZR at Kino's) called "The Paradox of Choice: Why More is Less" by Barry Schwarz.
And it got me thinking about a few things that I've been pondering, for quite a while, on my own. Some of the thoughts in this book, is helping me refine some of these reflections.
I've been thinking about my generation. Malaysia's baby boom generation - identified as those born between the years 1967 to 1978 - and those that come after that. And the reasons why some trends have become so prevalent, within this generation.
This is a generation that has MORE of everything. Education, Information, wealth, knowledge, exposure to the outside world through print and electronic media, freedom, choice and expectations. They have more of everything - more than previous generations were ever, fortunate enough to experience.
And yet there are more divorces, more crass materialism, more obsessions with beauty, more suicides, more sexual violence, freedom, promiscuity and diseases, more social problems, more abortions, more underage sex, more extra-marital affairs, more smoking and more alcoholic beverages consumption (by both Muslims and non-Muslims) than ever, in Malaysia.
There used to be a time when moral and cultural norms kept Malaysians within a certain confined moral existence. It was restrictive - people did not question what they were following, because their parents, their leaders, their culture and their religion, ordered them to follow.
There used to be a time, when the whole kampung was your extended family and everyone else's elders are your "parents" too - especially on keeping the young on the straight and narrow.
Now we live in cities. Some of us don't live with our parents, even when we're single and in the same city. Some of us, don't know our neighbours, much less their elders. Some have never stepped into the neighbourhood mosque and met the Imam there. Some Malays hardly speak Malay anymore and most Chinese can't speak or write proper Mandarin, anymore.
This generation likes its space, its individuality. Its freedom not to be bound by the norms of yesterday. Today's generation is more educated than yesterday's generation. Nothing is accepted willy-nilly anymore. The strength of the cultural and religious norms don't hem you in, anymore. You resist societal pressure to conform, whether openly or you rebel in discreet.
This generation knows it has a choice. Education gives them the right to believe that they can be anything they want. That they don't have to fall under any particular labels, roles or character - man, husband, leader, father, woman, wife, mother, married, chaste, loyal.
This generation chooses what it wants to be. As Dato' Seri Musa Hitam used to say: "You can't give people an education and expect them not to think".
I'm not sure "thinking" is the correct word, though.
But this generation is for sure - rejecting. Rejecting anything that stops them from being themselves, that stops them from being happy, that stops them from celebrating their individualities.
Rejecting limits, rejecting bullshit by politicians, rejecting nationalism - after all they are global citizens - they can be happy anywhere around the world, can't they? Rejecting the thought that economic growth is not continuous in Malaysia.
Rejecting religion and anything that reeks of being judgmental. Rejecting race and conformity stereotypes. Rejecting anything that limits choice and freedom.
And this generation EXPECTS to be happy. They don't think they are blessed if they get it - they consider it a birthright, a compulsory element, a must-have, the point of all things. For everyone. Anyone that's not happy - is just really a party-pooper, a drag.
And happiness is non-negotiable, for many today. Whatever the price, whatever norms they break, regardless of how many families they shatter. They've learned the all-important word and person - ME. The individual must be limitless, in his pursuit of happiness - let not God or Man stand in his way.
So much education, even of the wrong types. So much choice, to choose from. So many expectations to fulfill.
No chains. Free from restrictions. Free from dogma - except the right to be happy. That's the ultimate truth, not dogma. Or so they think.
**********************************************************************************
Reminds me of a passage from Kahlil Gibran:
"The woman of yesterday was a happy wife,
but the woman of today is a miserable mistress.
In the past, she walked blindly in the light,
but no she walks open-eyed in the dark.
She was beautiful in her ignorance,
virtuous in her simplicity,
and strong in her weakness.
Today, she has become ugly in her ingenuity,
superficial and heartless in her knowledge"
And in another part of the same story, Gibran wrote:
"This strange generation exists between sleeping and waking".
**********************************************************************************
What's my point?
It's the irony of it all. For a generation that has managed to break free of the chains of yesterday's generation - poverty, illiteracy, tyranny, colonization, sexual chauvinism, royal oppression, tradition, etc. - it seems to be trapped in a cell with invisible bars, of its own making.
This generation has no wish to escape this cell. It only knows what it doesn't want. It doesn't necessarily know where its going and whether that destination is a good place.
And whether those expectations are reasonable - how does one measure, if one has no conception of a life, with limits? And blurring lines of right and wrong?
What this generation is asking for, is the individual right and choice - to be lost. In their own world and expectations.
***********************************************************************************
Perhaps, this generation is more educated. But it lacks wisdom - for knowledge is meaningless, without knowing the value of moral restraint.
And it got me thinking about a few things that I've been pondering, for quite a while, on my own. Some of the thoughts in this book, is helping me refine some of these reflections.
I've been thinking about my generation. Malaysia's baby boom generation - identified as those born between the years 1967 to 1978 - and those that come after that. And the reasons why some trends have become so prevalent, within this generation.
This is a generation that has MORE of everything. Education, Information, wealth, knowledge, exposure to the outside world through print and electronic media, freedom, choice and expectations. They have more of everything - more than previous generations were ever, fortunate enough to experience.
And yet there are more divorces, more crass materialism, more obsessions with beauty, more suicides, more sexual violence, freedom, promiscuity and diseases, more social problems, more abortions, more underage sex, more extra-marital affairs, more smoking and more alcoholic beverages consumption (by both Muslims and non-Muslims) than ever, in Malaysia.
There used to be a time when moral and cultural norms kept Malaysians within a certain confined moral existence. It was restrictive - people did not question what they were following, because their parents, their leaders, their culture and their religion, ordered them to follow.
There used to be a time, when the whole kampung was your extended family and everyone else's elders are your "parents" too - especially on keeping the young on the straight and narrow.
Now we live in cities. Some of us don't live with our parents, even when we're single and in the same city. Some of us, don't know our neighbours, much less their elders. Some have never stepped into the neighbourhood mosque and met the Imam there. Some Malays hardly speak Malay anymore and most Chinese can't speak or write proper Mandarin, anymore.
This generation likes its space, its individuality. Its freedom not to be bound by the norms of yesterday. Today's generation is more educated than yesterday's generation. Nothing is accepted willy-nilly anymore. The strength of the cultural and religious norms don't hem you in, anymore. You resist societal pressure to conform, whether openly or you rebel in discreet.
This generation knows it has a choice. Education gives them the right to believe that they can be anything they want. That they don't have to fall under any particular labels, roles or character - man, husband, leader, father, woman, wife, mother, married, chaste, loyal.
This generation chooses what it wants to be. As Dato' Seri Musa Hitam used to say: "You can't give people an education and expect them not to think".
I'm not sure "thinking" is the correct word, though.
But this generation is for sure - rejecting. Rejecting anything that stops them from being themselves, that stops them from being happy, that stops them from celebrating their individualities.
Rejecting limits, rejecting bullshit by politicians, rejecting nationalism - after all they are global citizens - they can be happy anywhere around the world, can't they? Rejecting the thought that economic growth is not continuous in Malaysia.
Rejecting religion and anything that reeks of being judgmental. Rejecting race and conformity stereotypes. Rejecting anything that limits choice and freedom.
And this generation EXPECTS to be happy. They don't think they are blessed if they get it - they consider it a birthright, a compulsory element, a must-have, the point of all things. For everyone. Anyone that's not happy - is just really a party-pooper, a drag.
And happiness is non-negotiable, for many today. Whatever the price, whatever norms they break, regardless of how many families they shatter. They've learned the all-important word and person - ME. The individual must be limitless, in his pursuit of happiness - let not God or Man stand in his way.
So much education, even of the wrong types. So much choice, to choose from. So many expectations to fulfill.
No chains. Free from restrictions. Free from dogma - except the right to be happy. That's the ultimate truth, not dogma. Or so they think.
**********************************************************************************
Reminds me of a passage from Kahlil Gibran:
"The woman of yesterday was a happy wife,
but the woman of today is a miserable mistress.
In the past, she walked blindly in the light,
but no she walks open-eyed in the dark.
She was beautiful in her ignorance,
virtuous in her simplicity,
and strong in her weakness.
Today, she has become ugly in her ingenuity,
superficial and heartless in her knowledge"
And in another part of the same story, Gibran wrote:
"This strange generation exists between sleeping and waking".
**********************************************************************************
What's my point?
It's the irony of it all. For a generation that has managed to break free of the chains of yesterday's generation - poverty, illiteracy, tyranny, colonization, sexual chauvinism, royal oppression, tradition, etc. - it seems to be trapped in a cell with invisible bars, of its own making.
This generation has no wish to escape this cell. It only knows what it doesn't want. It doesn't necessarily know where its going and whether that destination is a good place.
And whether those expectations are reasonable - how does one measure, if one has no conception of a life, with limits? And blurring lines of right and wrong?
What this generation is asking for, is the individual right and choice - to be lost. In their own world and expectations.
***********************************************************************************
Perhaps, this generation is more educated. But it lacks wisdom - for knowledge is meaningless, without knowing the value of moral restraint.
12 Comments:
then again bro being knowledgeable does not necessarily makes you wise.
To quote one of the quotes you quoted (haha i love this phrase):
"The art of being wise is knowing what to overlook" - William James
wisdom requires a person to be eccletic and experience all sorts of things.
you dont get to be that by being apathetic.
Experienced, but messed up. I wonder how messed up could you be when you have an observation as astute as this?
When one rejects the boundary and the limit, and when one see them as restrictive instead of natural guide of one's actions - that's when one goes haywire. Nothing to grab and hold on to when things go tough.
Of course, this generation likes to set their own subjective 'boundaries' which, more often than not, exceed the existing and time-tried ones.
Now that you have identified the issue, perhaps it's productive for those who recognize the issue in their lives, to think and act on how to move forward in rediscovering the lost wisdom.
oh puh-lease! get off your high horse. your self-righteousness is showcased brilliantly in this piece. it's a wonder you're alone. Not!
Sharizal:
I never said being knowledgeable makes you wise, bro'.
What I'm saying is that this generation seems to be even more lost, despite more knowledge.
Yes, I agree with you that you can't get wisdom, by being apathetic.
But neither can you get there - without knowing what are the limits, that are good and bad, for you.
Voice:
Touche. :) But the journey is still long for me, Voice.
Disgusted:
Am sorry, if I sounded self-righteous to you.
And I did not get on the high horse - have lost my horse a long time ago. I've so many mistakes in my life, I'm not entitled to a horse. ;)
When I was making this observation about this lost generation, that includes me. Particularly me.
As for being alone - perhaps, that's my lot in life, right now. And I accept it.
Psuedonym0us:
Thanks.
But yes, sometimes, I do feel that we tend to measure having more and going forward as progress - as opposed to asking, where we're going.
To what extent is this a problem of urbanisation - eg are divorce rates, violent crimes higher in urban areas compared to rural Malaysia?
Also, the baby boom generation may have a lot of everything but they seem to lack (again maybe confined to the urban/suburbanites) real or even simulated hardship. There are fewer "character building situations" for us to endure compared to the generation before.
It is going to be a real challenge bringing up the next generation.
Anon 2
I don't think the whole episode you wrote is because the generation lacks wisdom with the increased knowledge. But rather because people no longer hold on to the traditional values as much as before.
We justify to ourselves that those values are no longer applicable. We tell ourselves that we need to be more liberal and open. We view certain values as limitations to actions and to this, I disagree with.
ahaa... glad that you include yourself in this 'lost generation' lot.
As for me, I am reading the Quran (translated one) to better understand everything. Because everything, including this paradox comes from Him.
Wa'allahuallam.
Anon 2:
I don't think it's so much an urban/rural divide. It's happening across the board, with this generation.
For instance, Kelantan has the highest divorce, polygamy and drug addiction rates, in the country.
The social problems and moral decay in some parts of Kedah, is disturbing.
I don't think we lack "character building situations" in the city. It's just that the challenges are more "invisible and subtle" and overwhelms you before you knew what hit you.
Thinktankgal:
Next generation, if we're not careful, will be like the Gen. 2 car - looks great on the outside, but has an obvious internal design defect. ;)
Anon:
It is due to knowledge and exposure, that people tend to question tradition.
Admittedly, not all traditions are good. Some should be questioned on its applicability, in this day and age.
It's fine if they maintained the good ones and threw out the bad ones.
But the problem comes when they're assimilating into a so-called "progressive" tradition and culture, which is not from our cultural roots and is corrosive to the good things, in our way of life.
:) said:
Yes, am very much a part of this generation. :)
Good for you that you're following up on your Quranic studies.
After all, we have one certainty - His promise that we will not be lost, for as long as we hang on to His "rope" - Al-Quran.
Oprah once interviewed a columnist who once declared that she loved her husband more than her children. Of course, you can imagine the furor this caused. The discussion that followed revealed something.
We are a privileged but lost generation. In our parents' (and society's) quest to create better human beings, we were made to be the centre of their universe, and hence, grew up to be a generation of "want" rather than need, one where the centre is "me" rather than "us".
The writer on Oprah made a great point, by focusing on her relationship with her husband, she is teaching her children how to have human relationships - something most parents neglect in their quest to squeeze 15,000 languages into their children's heads.
Perhaps as children, we had less time to play and socialise, and hence, all this knowledge that we have has no context to the world around us.
If this is true, it looks like our generation of parents are amplifying the same mistakes our parents made, and inadvertantly creating an even "more lost" generation.
Eh, not to be facetious but please dish out scoop on Gen 2...what are these internal design defects that you speak of?
Thinktankgal:
Golf GTI? You mean, you want them to grow up fast, smooth, powerful, sexy and growling? ;)
Najah:
Very interesting point. Food for thought.
On the one hand, we've got to teach our children to compete (in a world that's obsessed with it) and on the other, to take time to relate to and think of, other human beings.
Tall order for parenting. Yikes!
Elina:
Actually, the internal design defect is a matter of perspective. If you're not above 1.7 metres in height, the backseat wouldn't bother you.
But if you ARE (like 1.78 metres me), then your head will get well acquainted with the ceiling of the car roof.
Otherwise, you may be short of complaints on the Gen. 2. (No pun intended)
(Apparently, a Proton executive that was interviewed about this feature said that the backseat was "meant for children", as it was a family car.)
No matter. We could still sell the car, to not very tall people and others outside the Western world. :)
Advertising can be a big problem otherwise. A lot of companies reserve a big chunk of their budgets to cover marketing expenditures.
Post a Comment
<< Home